Research and Markets


Printer Friendly

Printed from http://www.researchandmarkets.com/reports/1096000


Financial Services Marketing to DEs


Description: This Market Assessment considers the attitudes of lower income groups towards financial service providers and their own financial priorities. It also considers how financial service providers communicate with and influence their lower-earning customers. New consumer research is the centre piece of this report, supported by analyses of advertising data and discussion of business strategies and performance.

The low-income segment of the working-age population includes more than 7.1 million men and 8 million women. In addition there are more than 4.4 million men and nearly 7.6 million women over state pension age, around 2 million of whom are on very low incomes. In total, around 17.2 million adults in the UK are likely to have extremely limited financial resources.

Financial services for lower-income individuals and households, the D and E social grades, have shifted down towards the basic-insurance and emergency-credit end of the spectrum, because the income differential between the bulk of the population and those at the top of the scale has widened, and those at the lower end have little capacity to afford discretionary financial services. There is little scope for an increase in sales of complex financial services, such as long-term investments and defined-contribution pensions, to people with average to low incomes.

They cannot afford the risks, especially if they would also be throwing away their safety net of means-tested welfare benefits. Banking in the UK suffered critical changes between 2007 and 2009. Northern Rock and Bradford & Bingley Mortgages were nationalized, and the Government took a substantial stake in the merged Lloyds TSB and HBOS, and control of The Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS). Alliance & Leicester and Bradford & Bingley Savings joined Abbey in the Spanish group Santander.

Companies specializing in products popular with lower-income customers have experienced mixed fortunes. The sub-prime lender Cattles was, in summer 2009, struggling to avoid insolvency. Provident Financial, also a sub-prime lender, angered a majority of shareholders with its exuberant pay plans for directors and senior executives. London Scottish Bank, which catered particularly for low-income borrowers, went into administration in 2008. Pawnbrokers, on the other hand, have thrived. Debt-rescheduling companies, cheque cashers and firms that benefit from some customers' lack of financial awareness also tend to perform well in a recession.

Financial comparison sites such as confused.com, moneysupermarket.com, comparethemarket.com and gocompare.com have become a huge influence on the market since 2000, particularly in the categories of motor insurance and multi-product insurance. The most heavily advertised types of financial service are those required by law or under contract (motor insurance and buildings insurance for mortgagees), help for those seeking compensation (personal injury claims) and basic banking products (current accounts, instant-access savings and so on). In addition, large sums are spent on brand awareness building. Individuals with low to moderate incomes are sought after in the mass market for motor insurance, home insurance and regular savings, but loans for these groups slowed to a trickle in 2008/2009.

Extensive consumer research in June 2009 found that most of the below-average earners in the D and E social grades had not managed to increase their savings during the previous 12 months, and these consumers were among the most likely to have seen their savings fall. Nearly half of Ds and Es said they had less money in June 2009 than a year earlier. Older people were the most vulnerable to a slide in savings. Savings decline is far more a feature of 2009 than it was when the authors conducted its last survey on this topic, in 2006. Among the Ds in 2009, two in every nine said they had no savings at all. In the lowest-income group, the non-employed, part-time employed and casually employed Es, almost one in five had no savings.

Nationally, far more people obtain financial information from the Internet than from independent financial advisers (IFAs). More than three people in ten overall say that the Internet is their principal source of financial information, followed by newspapers, television and radio. For Ds and Es, television is the principal source of financial information. Older Ds and Es are very unlikely to obtain financial information from the Internet, and they are far behind the trend towards online banking.

Lower-income households have delicate calculations to make when deciding how much to save, because if they need to apply for means-tested benefits, they have to use up their savings, down to the level of maximum permitted capital, before they receive any state help. The means-testing rules mean that it is common sense for lower-income households to try to buy a home, rather than to save or invest. The home can then be converted into an income stream in retirement, through equity release, although means testing is a major consideration here too.

The abandonment of defined-benefit pensions is hard for lower-income workers, because they are unlikely to have sufficient disposable income to make the far higher contributions into defined-contribution schemes that are necessary to provide equivalent pensions.

Possible ways forward to improve financial security for lower earners include: credit unions, to offer savings and loans; the replacement of current state retirement provision with a higher basic state pension and a reduction in complex means-tested benefits; and state guarantees for home buildings insurance in zones that commercial insurers wish to exclude, notably because of high flood risk.

The many millions in the UK who work hard for modest pay have benefited little from global financial services, although they will pay in future taxation for the subsidies that the Government poured into failing banks. The role of means testing in discouraging individuals from saving is a worry because, as the numbers expecting or needing the state to support them escalate, the state will struggle and perhaps fail to meet the welfare demands upon it.

This is an important issue for public policy. The `stick' approach to the problem could be a phased withdrawal of means-tested benefits, while the `carrot' approach could include the creation of individual accounts in a new contributory national provident fund, with backing from the state. Individuals would be able to make withdrawals in cases of prolonged illness, disability or unemployment, and in old age.


Contents: Executive Summary

1. Introduction
BACKGROUND
The UK Population by Occupational Classification
Table 1.1: The UK Government’s Former and Current
Occupational Classifications, 2009
Table 1.2: The UK Working-Age Population by Sex and Occupational Classification —
Current or Last Job (% and 000), Autumn 2005
Table 1.3: Estimated Size of Lower Income Groups in the UK
Working-Age Population by Sex and Occupational Classification —
Current or Last Job (000), First Quarter 2009
Sources of Information
DEFINITION

2. Strategic Overview
MARKET DYNAMICS
Market Issues
Market Status
Table 2.1: Average Weekly UK Household Expenditure on Life Assurance and Pensions,
Medical Insurance, Friendly Societies and Other Insurance, Savings and Investments,
and Debt Consolidation Loans by Income Decile Group (£), 2007
DISTRIBUTION
COMPETITIVE STRUCTURE
ADVERTISING
THE CONSUMER
June 2006
June 2009
MARKET OUTLOOK
Turnings Assets into Cash
Short-Term Products
KEY POINTS

3. Income Patterns
INCOMES PEAK BEFORE AGE 50
Table 3.1: Average Weekly UK Household Income by Source and
Age of Household Reference Person (% and £), 2004/2005
Table 3.2: Average Weekly UK Household Income by Source and
Age of Household Reference Person (% and £), 2007
Table 3.3: Percentage Changes in Average Weekly UK Household Income
by Age of Household Reference Person, 2001/2002-2004/2005 and 2004/2005-2007
INCOMES LAG IN OLD INDUSTRIAL CITIES
Table 3.4: The UK Parliamentary Constituencies with the Lowest Median
Annual Incomes (£), 2003/2004 and 2006/2007
LOW PENSIONS IN URBAN AND RURAL AREAS
Table 3.5: The UK Parliamentary Constituencies with the Lowest Median
Annual Pension Incomes (£), 2003/2004 and 2006/2007
SELF-EMPLOYMENT INCOME IS STAGNANT
Table 3.6: The UK Parliamentary Constituencies with the Lowest Median
Annual Incomes from Self-Employment (£), 2003/2004 and 2006/2007
WOMEN’S LOW INCOMES
Table 3.7: Estimated Number of Taxpayers by Sex
and Annual Income (000, % and number), 2006/2007
Figure 3.1: Estimated Number of Male Taxpayers
by Annual Income (000), 2006/2007
Figure 3.2: Estimated Number of Female Taxpayers
by Annual Income (000), 2006/2007
OCCUPATIONS WITH MODEST PAY PACKETS
Table 3.8: The Occupations with the Lowest Median Weekly Earnings for Full-Time
Male Employees in the UK (000 jobs, % of employees and £), 2005 and 2008
Table 3.9: The Occupations with the Lowest Median Weekly Earnings for Full-Time
Female Employees in the UK (000 jobs, % of employees and £), 2005 and 2008
KEY POINTS

4. Household Wealth
FEW ASSETS APART FROM HOMES
Table 4.1: Net Wealth of the UK Household Sector by Type of Asset
and Type of Liability at Constant 2007 Prices (£bn), 1991-2007
SAVINGS: VERY LITTLE OR A LOT
Table 4.2: UK Household Savings Profile (%),
2001/2002, 2004/2005 and 2007/2008
LOW PARTICIPATION IN FINANCIAL SERVICES
Table 4.3: UK Household Participation in Financial Services by Type of Product
by Total Weekly Household Income (%), 2004/2005
KEY POINTS

5. Basic Banking
BASIC ACCOUNTS — STILL NOT FOR ALL
PAY BEFORE YOU BUY
CHEQUE CASHING
ALTERNATIVES TO BANK BRANCHES
KEY POINTS

6. Supermarket Banking
2009: YEAR OF OPPORTUNITY
SAINSBURY’S BANK
TESCO PERSONAL FINANCE
ASDA
MARKS & SPENCER
THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP
KEY POINTS

7. Savings
SHORT-TERM SAVINGS
Little Point in Saving Over £6,000
Minimal Interest Rates
Static Demand
Table 7.1: Average Weekly UK Household Expenditure on Selected
Financial Products (£), 1997/1998, 2001/2002, 2004/2005 and 2007
National Savings & Investments
Table 7.2: National Savings & Investments — Sample Interest Rates
by Product (%), 1999-2009
LONG-TERM SAVINGS
Short-Term Attitudes
Killing Off Occupational Pensions
Friendly Societies
Paying for Care
KEY POINTS

8. Loans
WEIGHTY DEBTS
Table 8.1: Indebtedness to Individuals and Housing Associations in the UK
(£m and index 30th June 2001=100), 30th June 2001-2009
EQUITY RELEASE — A LOAN FROM ONESELF
Table 8.2: Main Media Advertising Expenditure on Equity Release
by Brand (£000), Year Ending 31st March 2009
SHORT-TERM CREDIT
HOME CREDIT
CATALOGUE FINANCE AND STORE CREDIT
CREDIT UNIONS
MICROFINANCE
DEBT COLLECTORS
KEY POINTS

9. Advertising and Promotion
RISE OF COMPARISON SITES
SIMPLE PRODUCTS DOMINATE ADVERTISING
Table 9.1: Main Media Advertising Expenditure on Financial Services
by Sector (£000 and %), Year Ending 31st March 2009
CARS AND HOMES
Table 9.2: Main Media Advertising Expenditure on Car Insurance
by Brand (£000 and %), Year Ending 31st March 2009
Table 9.3: Main Media Advertising Expenditure on Home Insurance
by Brand (£000 and %), Year Ending 31st March 2009
LIGHT ON LIFE
MONEY HANDLING
EMERGENCIES AND SAVINGS
Table 9.4: Main Media Advertising Expenditure on Accountants, Solicitors and
Injury Claims by Brand (£000 and %), Year Ending 31st March 2009
TIGHT TARGETING
ACORN
CAMEO
Mosaic
KEY POINTS

10. An International Perspective
UNDEVELOPED MARKETS OFFER LITTLE COMMERCIAL ATTRACTION
THE US — SELF-HELP AND CHURCHES
OPPORTUNITIES IN HOME CREDIT
MICROFINANCE
KEY POINTS

11. PEST Analysis
POLITICAL FACTORS
Proposed Banking Act
Consumer Credit Act
Reducing Financial Exclusion
The Minimum Wage
ECONOMIC FACTORS
Losing Jobs
Table 11.1: Number of Male Workforce Jobs in the UK
by Industry (000), March 2008 and 2009
Figure 11.1: Number of Male Workforce Jobs in the UK
by Industry (000), March 2008 and 2009
Table 11.2: Number of Female Workforce Jobs in the UK
by Industry (000), March 2008 and 2009
Figure 11.2: Number of Female Workforce Jobs in the UK
by Industry (000), March 2008 and 2009
Young Households Hard-Pressed Financially
Table 11.3: Average Gross Weekly Household Income and Household Expenditure
in the UK by Age of Household Reference Person (£), 2007
SOCIAL FACTORS
TECHNOLOGICAL FACTORS
KEY POINTS

12. Consumer Dynamics
INTRODUCTION
D AND E GRADES LAG IN SAVING
Table 12.1: My Savings Have Increased Over the Past Year
(% of respondents), 2009
DEFLATING THE CASH SAFETY CUSHION
Table 12.2: My Savings Have Decreased Over the Past Year
(% of respondents), 2009
NEARLY A QUARTER OF THE D GRADE HAVE NO SAVINGS
Table 12.3: I Have No Savings (% of respondents), 2009
TRYING TO LIMIT NEW DEBT
Table 12.4: My Debts Have Increased Over the Past Year
(% of respondents), 2009
EMPHASIS ON REPAYING EXISTING DEBT
Table 12.5: My Debts Have Decreased Over the Past Year
(% of respondents), 2009
THREE IN TEN ARE WITHOUT DEBTS
Table 12.6: I Have No Debts, Not Even a Mortgage
(% of respondents), 2009
RETIREMENT-INCOME FEARS
Table 12.7: Proportions of Ds and Es with Falling Savings,
No Savings and Rising Debts (%), 2009
Table 12.8: I Worry That My Retirement Income is, or Will Be,
Insufficient to Live on Comfortably (% of respondents), 2009
PROPERTY RETAINS ALLURE
Table 12.9: Property is the Best Investment for a Pension
(% of respondents), 2009
ADVISER CONSULTATIONS PEAK PRE-RETIREMENT
Table 12.10: I Have Consulted an Independent Financial Adviser
Within the Past Year (% of respondents), 2009
FEWER WORRIES ABOUT ADVICE COSTS
Table 12.11: Independent Financial Advice is Too Expensive
for Me to Afford (% of respondents), 2009
INTERNET IS MAIN SOURCE OF FINANCIAL ADVICE —
BUT NOT FOR THE D OR E GRADES
Table 12.12: I Rely Principally on the Internet for Financial Information
(% of respondents), 2009
ELDERLY RATE NEWSPAPERS HIGHLY
Table 12.13: I Rely Principally on Newspapers for Financial Information
(% of respondents), 2009
LOWER INCOME GROUPS LOOK TO TELEVISION
Table 12.14: I Rely Principally on Television for Financial Information
(% of respondents), 2009
RADIO MOST POPULAR IN THE A AND D GRADES
Table 12.15: I Rely Principally on the Radio for Financial Information
(% of respondents), 2009
POOR AND ELDERLY LAG IN ACCESS TO FINANCIAL INFORMATION
Table 12.16: I Do Not Rely Principally on Any of These Sources for
Financial Information (% of respondents), 2009
OLDER AND POORER PEOPLE LAG IN ONLINE BANKING
Table 12.17: I Bank Online (% of respondents), 2009
ONLINE CONFIDENCE ISSUES
Table 12.18: I Have Full Confidence in Online Banking
(% of respondents), 2009
KEY POINTS

13. Company Profiles
INTRODUCTION
HIGH-STREET BANKS: INDEPENDENTS
Barclays
Table 13.1: Barclays PLC — Financial Performance
(£000, number, £ and %), Years Ending 31st December 2006-2008
HSBC
Table 13.2: HSBC Holdings PLC — Financial Performance
($000, number, $ and %), Years Ending 31st December 2006-2008
Lloyds Banking Group
Table 13.3: Lloyds Banking Group PLC — Financial Performance
(£000, number, £ and %), Years Ending 31st December 2006-2008
Grupo Santander (Spain)
HIGH-STREET BANKS: STATE CONTROLLED
Northern Rock
Table 13.4: Northern Rock PLC — Financial Performance
(£000, number, £ and %), Years Ending 31st December 2006-2008
The Royal Bank of Scotland
Table 13.5: The Royal Bank of Scotland Group PLC — Financial Performance
(£000, number, £ and %), Years Ending 31st December 2006-2008
INSURANCE COMPANIES
Aviva (Norwich Union)
Table 13.6: Aviva PLC — Financial Performance
(£000, number, £ and %), Years Ending 31st December 2006-2008
Legal & General
Table 13.7: Legal & General Group PLC — Financial Performance
(£000, number, £ and %), Years Ending 31st December 2006-2008
Prudential
Table 13.8: Prudential PLC — Financial Performance
(£000, number, £ and %), Years Ending 31st December 2006-2008
RSA
Table 13.9: RSA Insurance Group PLC — Financial Performance
(£000, number, £ and %), Years Ending 31st December 2006-2008
NATIONAL SAVINGS AND THE POST OFFICE
National Savings & Investments
The Post Office
Table 13.10: Post Office Ltd — Financial Performance
(£000, number, £ and %), Year Ending 26th March 2007, 53 Weeks Ending
30th March 2008, and Year Ending 29th March 2009
NICHE ORGANISATIONS FOR THE LESS AFFLUENT
Cash Generator
Table 13.11: Cash Generator Ltd — Financial Performance
(£000, number, £ and %), Years Ending 31st January 2006-2008
Cattles
Table 13.12: Cattles PLC — Financial Performance
(£000, number, £ and %), Years Ending 31st December 2005-2007
Kensington Group
The Money Shop
Table 13.13: Instant Cash Loans Ltd — Financial Performance
(£000, number, £ and %), Years Ending 30th June 2006-2008
Park Group
PayPoint
Table 13.14: PayPoint PLC — Financial Performance
(£000, number, £ and %), 51 Weeks Ending 25th March 2007, 53 Weeks Ending
30th March 2008 and Year Ending 29th March 2009
Provident Financial
Table 13.15: Provident Financial PLC — Financial Performance
(£000, number, £ and %), Years Ending 31st December 2006-2008
KEY POINTS

14. The Future
NO COMMISSION, NO ADVICE?
LOW-COST LOANS: ARE THEY FEASIBLE?
SAVING WHEN INTEREST RATES ARE LOW
PENSIONS GAP
PROPERTY DOMINANT
MEANS TESTING IS THE ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM
BRANDS FOR TOMORROW’S LESS AFFLUENT
THE NEXT 5 YEARS
KEY POINTS

15. Glossary

16. Further Sources
Associations
General Sources
Government Sources
Other Sources
Key Note Sources


Companies Mentioned - Barclays - HSBC - Lloyds Banking Group - Grupo Santander (Spain) - Northern Rock - The Royal Bank of Scotland - Aviva (Norwich Union) - Legal & General - Prudential - RSA - Cash Generator - Cattles - Kensington Group - The Money Shop - Park Group - PayPoint - Provident Financial


Ordering: Order Online - visit http://www.researchandmarkets.com/reports/1096000

Order by Fax - using the order form below

Order By Post - print the order form below and send to

Research and Markets,
Guinness Centre,
Taylors Lane,
Dublin 8,
Ireland.


Research and Markets Page 1 of 2
Printed 15/02/2012 18:59:13
Fax Order Form
To place an order via fax simply print this form, fill in the information below and fax the completed form to
646-607-1907 (from USA) or +353 1 6849977 (from Rest of World). If you have any questions please email help@researchandmarkets.net

Order information
Please verify that the product information is correct and select the format you require.
Product Name:
Financial Services Marketing to DEs

Web Address:
http://www.researchandmarkets.com/reports/1096000

Office Code:
OC8IHINLSNNSS

Report formats
Please enter the quantity of the report format you require.

Format Quantity Price
Electronic (PDF) - Single User €1,582.00
Hard Copy €1,758.00 + EUR€ 50.00 Shipping/Handling *
* Shipping/Handling is only charged once per order.


Contact information
Please enter all the information below in BLOCK CAPITALS.

First Name:   Last Name:  
Email Address:
Job Title:
Organisation:
Address:
City:
Postal/Zip Code:
Country:
Phone Number:
Fax Number:


Please fax this form to:
(646) 607-1907 or (646) 964-6609 (from USA)
+353-1-481-1716 or +353-1-653-1571 (from Rest of World)
Research and Markets Page 2 of 2
Printed 15/02/2012 18:59:13


Payment information

Please indicate the payment method you would like to use by selecting the appropriate box.

 Pay by Credit Card:
American Express
Diners Club
Master Card
Visa
Cardholder's Name:
Cardholder's Signature:
Expiry Date: /
Card Number:
CVV Security Code:
Issue Date: /   (Diners Club only)


 Pay by Check:
Please post the check, accompanied by this form, to:

Research and Markets,
Guinness Centre,
Taylors Lane,
Dublin 8,
Ireland.


 Pay by Wire Transfer:
Please transfer funds to:

Account number: 83313083
Sort code: 98-53-30
Swift code: ULSBIE2D
IBAN number: IE78ULSB98533083313083
Bank Address: Ulster Bank,
27-35 Main St,
Blackrock,
Co. Dublin,
Ireland.
If you have a Marketing Code please enter it below:
Marketing Code:


Please note that by ordering from Research and Markets you are agreeing to our Terms and Conditions at http://www.researchandmarkets.com/info/terms.asp

Please fax this form to:
(646) 607-1907 or (646) 964-6609 (from USA)
+353-1-481-1716 or +353-1-653-1571 (from Rest of World)