With clear insight and the chemical as well as philosophical wisdom of more than fifty years as a practising chemist, Jerome Berson puts their theories to the test. The development of chemistry into a "modern" science during the last two centuries provides him with ample cases to illustrate the way scientific progress really happens.
Kekulé′s struggle to arrive at a structure for benzene, the paradigm change that was necessary to accept the reality of molecular rearrangements, and other episodes are retold here from the philosopher′s as well as from the practitioner′s perspective, shedding light on the way scientists think and act.
Berson′s account of the rather unphilosophical way in which scientific discoveries are made includes the realization that even a false hypothesis, such as Woodward′s ideas about the biosynthesis of strychnine and many other alkaloids, may help rather than hinder scientific progress.
Scientists of all ages, as well as many non–scientists, will find book to be highly readable and insightful.
Theories Built up from Observations. The Inductivist Ideal
Theories from Anywhere: Popper′s Philosophy of Conjections and Refutations
Refutation by Internal Contradiction. Kekule′s ′Hypothesis of Embarrassment′ and the Theory of Benzene
Are Crucial Experiments Conclusive? Refutations: Permanent, Temporary, and Virtual
Farewell to Stasis, Welcome to Metamorphosis: Refutation of Kekule′s Rule of Minimal Structural Change in the Discovery of Molecular Rearrangements
Some Non–Refutative Motivations in Science
False but Nevertheless Fruitful Theories. Speculations on the Biogenesis of Alkaloids
Stephan J. Weininger
Angewandte Chemie, 2003
"′Chemical Discovery′ is a fascinating book that should be of interest to both chemists and philosophers. Through insightful analysis of historical examples, Berson′s important book will undoubtedly serve as a useful introduction to some of the core philosophical issues about theory testing to students and practitioners of chemistry... The book could profitably play a key role in a seminar about the methodology or philosophy of chemistry, a use of which I hope to put the book myself. It is philosophically stimulating and ... makes many valuable points. I hope that the book will stimulate similar future projects, perhaps collaborations between chemists and philosophers of science."
Michael Weisberg, University of Pennsylvania
Chemical Engineering News, March22, 2004
"Chemical Discovery and the Logician′s Program is a welcome addition to the literature of philosophy and history of science from the perspective of a thoughtful practitioner of chemistry."
Carmen J. Giunta, Le Moyne College, Syracuse, NY
Bulletin for the History of Chemistry 1/2004
"...offers us valuable insights into the emergence of novel chemical paradigms."
Chemistry and Industry, Vol.2, No.2, February 2005
Choice, Vol. 41, No. 8, April 2004
Pierre Laszlo, HYLE – International Journal for Philosophy of Chemistry, Vol. 10 2004, No. 1